Well, the Galveston trip was a while ago, but with all of the work from my other classes, it took me quite a while to get through the book Isaac’s Storm. But that’s nothing against the book itself. To be honest, I thought it was outstanding. Normally, I like to be very critical of books and lectures (see my blog on the Constitution Day keynote), but I really don’t have too much bad to say about this book.
I guess I’ll start with that, so that the finish is the good parts, and, really, those are what I want you to remember. Now, one thing I will say about the “bad things” that this book did, is that I don’t think that they are bad things. As previously stated, I loved the book. I’m just going t say things that other people might not like. As a book on history, if you are looking for a dry description of the Hurricane of Nineteen Hundred, full of facts, written in a timeline manner which looks at figures and things which are absolutely factual, taken from primary sources, this book is not for you. It is a very personal look at the people who lived and died in the worst natural disaster in U.S. history.
So, now on to what I think made this book so great. It was personal. A quick Google search will get you all the facts of the storm. You would learn all the same figures, all the same names, dates, everything. But it isn’t the same. Isaac’s Storm is all about putting you in the shoes of the people who experienced this horror. It reads like a novel. And the best part is that it does it from a factual standpoint. It isn’t an historical fiction. The people aren’t larger than life (other than those who actually were) characters, who throw out perfect quotes about what they go through. Instead, the book goes through the timeline leading up to, during, and after the storm in a way that reads as a novel, yet, at the same time, being something, somehow, different.
That’s the thing. I can’t really describe how I felt reading Isaac’s Storm. I loved it, I really did, but it was different than any other book I’ve ever read. As the book wound through the stories of people as their homes were inundated or swept away by the storm, it pushed the bounds of what a factual book should do, focusing on the human suffering side, how parents must have felt knowing their children would die, and other such horrors. To me, that was great, but I recognize that others may not share that view. But remember, this was not a romantic story pulled from the author’s mind. It is solidly researched; the dialogue of the book was all actually said.
So, those are my thoughts on the book. Is it for everyone? No. No, it really isn’t. But if you accept it for what it is, then it can grab you. In all honesty, I have to admit, this book, literally, by itself, convinced me to vow never to live on the coast. That’s the impact it had on me. Do I really need to say anything else?



